Recently, our class of A Level Media studies had been introduced to a number of theories regarding film analysis. These theories included topics of characters in film, narrative structure, and overall conventions found in film plots.
The three theories I will be using to help analyze my chosen film trilogy, Lord Of The Rings are firstly, the Theory Of Binary Oppositions- Levi Strauss, second, Character Theory- Vladimir Propp and lastly Tzevtan Todorov’s Narrative theory.
The Lord Of The Rings is a series of 3 films (The Fellowship Of The Ring, The Two Towers and The Return of the King.) whose plots, characters and narratives are derived from the original books written by J.R.R Tolkien.
Below, I will be giving my understanding of each theory and analyzing the films broadly using them.
- The Theory Of Binary Oppositions- Levi Strauss: This theory revolves around the idea that a narrative makes use of contrast by implementing opposing main characters or themes. This idea may help thicken a plot or help add organized elements to the narrative that would make it more attractive to the target audience; a relevant example being Good vs Evil.
In the Lord Of The Rings trilogy, an obvious theme of Good Vs Evil can be observed as there is war involving the protagonist (Frodo Baggins) and his team of “good” characters (The fellowship of the ring- characters including Samwise Gamgee, Aragorn, Gimli, Merry, Pippin, Boromir, Legolas and Gandalf.) vs the antagonist (Sauron) and his team of “evil” characters (Saruman, Orcs, Uruk-hai, etc.). While there are grudges held between characters and communities within the plot in a small scale, mankind, elf-kind and other creatures fight for the “good” side alongside the people of Rohan against Saruman’s army towards the end. This reinforces the presence of a Good Vs Bad theme in The Lord Of The Rings, as the films depict various characters coming together, picking their side and fighting the large scale battle.
The level of depth that this overall theme (Good Vs Evil) and smaller nuances of the film (such as character arcs, interactions and histories) have added to the plot is incredible; allowing for 3 feature films that are each more than 2 hours long as well as adding detail to every character appearing on screen, making the viewer’s experience a truly memorable one. According to Box Office Mojo, the Lord of the Rings films have each earned an average of $970 million apiece.
2. Character Theory- Vladimir Propp: This theory discusses the conventional characters that may be found in many narratives. These character tropes include The Hero,The Dispatcher, The Helper, The Prize, The Donor, The Villain and the False Hero.
In The Lord Of The Ring, these character tropes can be observed easily. However, each character has various aspects to their personality and actions. Hence, they be perceived differently based on a viewer’s opinion. Having said that, my character role interpretation is as follows:
- The Hero– Frodo Baggins
- The Helper– Samwise Gamgee
- The Prize– Peace or to “save the good left in middle earth”
- The Dispatcher– Gandalf The Grey
- The Villain– Sauron
- The Donor– Aragorn, Smeagol
- The False Hero– Boromir
As nearly every character in the Lord Of The Rings series has a well developed character arc, it is difficult to place them in conventional character roles. However, characters such as the Hero, Dispatcher, Helper and Villain remain clear.
3. Narrative Theory- Tzvetan Todorov: The Narrative theory suggests that each plot has a 5 part segmentation including the following sections:
- Equilibrium
- Disruption
- Quest
- Climax
- New Equilibrium/Restoration
In the 3 films in the LOTR Franchise, this narrative structure is used quite creatively.
In the first film, the introduction or origin story of the ring and how it reached Bilbo Baggins itself makes use of Todorov’s shorter narrative theory involving only 3 steps: Equilibrium, Destruction, New Equilibrium. The usage of this shorter narrative theory in Fellowship Of The Ring as well as the 5 step version spread out across all 3 films in the franchise show us just how vast the story is and allows for more seamless narration- it may help audiences understand the plot further as they are given enough context to enjoy the film while staying true to the original book and plot.
After this introduction, The Fellowship Of The Ring or film one continues into usage of the 5 step narrative theory. My observations regarding this are as follows:
- Equilibrium: Bilbo and Frodo Bagins seemingly regular life in the Shire.
- Disruption: The return of Sauron.
- Quest: Frodo and the Fellowship Of The Ring traveling to Mordor to destroy The Ring.
- Climax: Gollum’s death, the destruction of the Ring and the end of Sauron.
- New Equilibrium/Restoration: Aragorn is crowned King of Gondor with Arwen as his queen, Samwise returns to the shire and has a family and Frodo leaves Middle-earth for the Undying Lands with his uncle Bilbo, Gandalf, and the Elves.